Friday, April 20, 2012

Personal Plea – Heartbreaking Consequences


Below is a message which I’ve steadfastly spread and adhered to for nearly 2 years since I began to Honor Them. Please read it in its entirety and the heartbreaking story which follows it.

The United States of America holds one of the most powerful military forces in the world. It is because of this that so many countries turn to us in their time of need. Sadly whether at war or in peace time, we do lose many brave sons and daughters who serve our great country. In a time of war, as we are now, those numbers increase. This is an inevitable yet heartbreaking part of war. When this happens, as a country we grieve. However, while we may be saddened by the loss of yet another one of our courageous men and women, that can’t possibly compare to the grief felt by their friends and family of the fallen. It is important that we put the feelings of their loved ones first, above all else.

The amount of posts on both Facebook and Twitter which pay tribute to our fallen heroes has been growing. In these posts many times the fallen hero’s name is given and sometimes even include their unit and branch as well. Normally I would say this is a wonderful thing, as part of my mission to Honor Them is to make sure that we all Honor Those Fallen so they are Never Forgotten for the tremendous sacrifice they’ve made on our behalf.

With that being said, an recurring problem for quite some time has been posts which are releasing sensitive information prior to the Department of Defense making an official release. It is important to know that the DOD releases this information only after the family has been notified. Losing a loved one is hard enough on these family members. The least we can all do is offer them the courtesy of making sure they receive notice in the most respectful and dignified manner possible.

Please remember and respect OPSEC (Operations Security) and the extremely sensitive nature of the information you have at your fingertips before you post anything, or relay information of any kind in any way, shape or form. Prematurely posting details regarding a casualty that a family member might see prior to being notified by the proper authorities is nothing I wish on any of the families of our fallen heroes.

Our brave and selfless troops fight to protect our freedoms and liberties. Let’s all work together to protect their families from any further hurt.

For the most part I think a majority of people understand the importance of the above message. However, I still find quite a few people who wish to debate the issue with me. Their reasons vary from “our local news reported it” or “my family readiness group posted it” or “I know someone in the unit and everyone is talking about it” or the one that makes me cringe the most “I saw it on Facebook and/or Twitter”.

Here is my problem with the above excuses – quite honestly that’s what they are is excuses, because they are not justifiable reasons to share sensitive information – the sources these people are obtaining this highly sensitive information from are not the Department of Defense. The DOD is the only entity which is permitted to put out a first notice/release of the death of one of our brave fallen heroes. No one else has that right, nor should they assume that they do.

This brings me to the reason for this blog entry. On April 3, 2012 we lost Fort Carson soldier, Staff Sgt. Christopher Brown due to wounds caused by an improvised explosive device. This in itself is tragic enough, however tragedy struck a second time for the family of Staff Sgt. Brown. Before I explain what happened, I’d like to give a little of background as to why I find the soon to be mentioned incident even more troubling and completely avoidable.

On April 4th I received a public request on Twitter asking me to honor and pay remembrance to Staff Sgt. Brown. My first reaction was to check the DOD site to see if I had perhaps missed a release. I was of course concerned when I saw that an official release had not yet been made regarding Staff Sgt. Brown. I sent this person (an Army wife) a private message requesting that she please delete her tweet with the soldiers name and explained my reasons why. I was surprised when I was met with some resistance on the subject. The reasons she gave me was that Staff Sgt. Brown was in her husband’s unit, their family readiness group had posted it and the family had been notified. I still chose to not publicly tweet the information and explained to her that in my way of Honoring Them, I will not post information on a death until I am 100% positive – meaning the DOD has made official release – that the family has been notified.

The debate ensued and I was surprised to received messages from other ‘wives of soldiers in the unit’ who requested that I pay public tribute to Staff Sgt. Christopher Brown. I have and will continue to Honor all of those brave we lose, however I will never do it until the DOD has made a release. It is because of this that I had to respectfully decline yet again and also explain my reasons why. I did find it odd that I received so many requests in such a short period of time (mere hours) for this one soldier and even went back through my messages this morning to make sure my memory wasn’t failing me before I wrote this post. My memory did not fail and I had more than one wife of a soldier requesting I publicly post this brave hero’s death information before the proper authorities had made such a release. An important side note to this is that the official release of Staff Sgt. Christopher Brown’s death was made by the DOD on April 5th. The day after these requests took place.

This morning I was saw the unfortunate result of what can happen when sensitive information gets into the wrong hands and causes tragic results.  Please click on this link: Wife of Fort Carson Soldier Learns of His Death on Facebook and read how crucial it is that everyone understand and respect OPSEC, and the information that somehow may have fallen into their hands. A similar incident happened in February when the wife of a fallen soldier received a phone call from her friend after reading about the death of the woman’s husband on Facebook.

Folks, my simple message to you is this: OPSEC exists for a reason. Our military forces have grown, thrived and remained strong on the principles of protecting Operations Security. We cannot hinder those who protect and defend us. It is our duty as Americans to use good sensibility with information. There should never be a rush to be the first to post sensitive information. I personally would rather be the last to post information regarding a death and know that the family was taken care of. Whether you serve, know someone who does, are in a military family or just read something on a social networking site, you still don’t have the authority to share the information publicly. No one does. Not until that fateful knock at the door happens, the family of our fallen have been taken care of and The Department of Defense has made an official release. The internet is a powerful tool, it has and can be used as a weapon, please use its strength wisely.

Very respectfully
 ~ Amanda

22 comments:

  1. Replies
    1. I agree whole heartedly Amanda!! Why someone would wish to rush a death notice is beyond me. I saw the article in question on facebook too. I hope all of the "Army Wives" who were so quick to pay repect for a fallen soldier BEFORE the soldiers family was notified are happy in some sick way. They are probably too stupid to know any better.

      Delete
    2. Thank you Amanda, for the way you handle this sensative information. I only wish everyone that uses social media were as thoughtful and kind. What a tragic way to learn that your spouse, child, sibling, etc. had passed away. I thank God daily for these brave men and women that put their lives on the line for our freedoms. The least they deserve is the respect of letting their family find out about their sacrifice in the most honorable way possible. God bless!

      Delete
    3. I can't Imagine how a family would feel finding out something this serious second hand...people treating loss of life like gossip is wrong on so many different levels!! I do admire you for standing up for this and not giving into the majority. I never put names up..just companies. I figure unless I have the families permission to use that name, I have no right.

      Delete
    4. I am a Air Force Mom and I agree with you 100%.... Nothing should be released UNTIL AFTER the family has been notified. It is heartbreaking to think what someone might do if not given the help/support right away because they learn over the internet or other means. These WIVES should put the shoe on the other foot and see how they would REALLY feel if they learned about it this way. I know I would be devastated. As with everyone else who has a loved one in the military, I hope I never have to experience the loss of my son. With that being said, I thank you as a MILITARY MOM for your stance on this issue.... HONOR THEM!!!

      Delete
    5. I agree too after my time overseas I served as the Sgt of the Honor Guard for many fallen soldiers. The military notifies they way they do for a reason the put together the team that will most help the family/spouse at the time they are notified. The NEVER NEED to hear it from anyone else except the Branch of service the fallen was serving

      Delete
  2. You are so right Amanda and this "family support" group and military spouses ought to know and respect that OPSEC is there for a reason. Not to keep our heros' deaths quiet but to keep the ones still there safer. Keep up the good work Amanda and go with your heart and your knoledge of what you are doing. I always try to post your last post of the day on my timeline and our group "friends of Patriot Guard Riders" telling us either we have or haven't lost anyone that day. Thanx for what you do.......An old disabled Vietnam

    ReplyDelete
  3. Amanda, thank you for your diligence and for always, always going above and beyond.

    My husband - a Navy SEAL for 32 years - had just retired completely when six months later he went for a bicycle ride and died of a massive heart attack.

    I was notified by a young local deputy sheriff who handed me a "sticky note" with Steve's name, the date and this notation: DOA. I will never forget the dishonor I felt on his behalf.

    The circumstances may be different, but this post speaks right to my heart. Thank you. ~Lynn Bukowski

    ReplyDelete
  4. Thank you, Amanda, for all you do, and may God bless you in your continued efforts to Honor Them. God bless our troops.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Thank you so much for what you do. It's an honor to be part of the wonderful site. If all people would just use simple respect and compassion, these families would never have to endure that kind of "shock" At least not in the way they heard about the death of their loved ones. I love you page, it in someway keeps me connected to my sailor, my youngest daughter. Some days I have to be reminded that there ARE people out there that support our Military,
    Sincerely, k. Hayes

    ReplyDelete
  6. I could not agree with you more! My son is a Marine, he is married. I would be beyond DEVASTATED to learn something on Facebook! He also has a few buddies in the Army whom I consider my "other boys" and the same applies there. I, for one, support you and how you operate. Very honorable Amanda. And Thank You, again, for what you do.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Misti Rogers McCollinApril 21, 2012 at 12:58 PM

    You know how I feel on this subject Amanda. Keep up the good work!

    ReplyDelete
  8. My Respect for you just went thru the ceiling.Thanks for all you do. May The Heavenly Father continually Bless and keep you Safe.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Hello Amanda, Thank you for all of your work and for your retweet of the message from "Honor For All" regarding the PTSD petition and HFA founder, Thomas Mahany, going to the White House on May 7th. Mr. Mahany would like to invite you to speak at the HFA annual event in Washington D.C. on June 27, 2012. Can you kindly email him at eldonstone@wowway.com for further details? I can't seem to locate your email address on your blog to send you his letter directly.
    Thank you,
    Kathy Fink

    ReplyDelete
  10. Bravo for standing your ground!!! You did what was right and if they can not understand that, I feel sorry for them and the family lives they may harm along the way

    ReplyDelete
  11. As a former FRG leader for 3 years, during 2 deployments, and as a FRSA, Family Readiness Support Assistant, Casualty Affairs is covered in length during Pre-Deployment briefings, FRG Meetings, and other opportunities where it can be useful training/reminders. As an Army wife of 9 years, and a Veteran before that, I as well was shocked and appalled when reading the article. It boils down to a complete lack or disregard of the regulations put in place to protect ourselves, which makes no sense. It is my firm hope that the soldier who started the problem, to the spouses who continued it, be dealt with accordingly by their Chain of Command. Also, protocol needs to be reevaluated as far as blackout all communication when such an incident happens. ALL COMMUNICATION. We had spouses who were angry with the world, and would start rumors about soldiers who will KIA, and weren't. It was a nightmare, but after being held accountable, it stopped.
    I, as well as many others appreciate all you do, and thank you for honoring those in the most appropriate way. I'm positive the families are grateful as well, and that's what truly matters. Thank you Amanda, for Honoring Them.
    Stephanie Pompa

    ReplyDelete
  12. I agree wholeheartedly with you. It is disgusting that some of the wives and family members can not understand this. How would they like it if they learned of their loved ones death that way.
    The military should be the first to notify the next of kin, not something posted on FB or Twitter.
    I was in military intelligence when I was in the Army and take it very seriously.
    Continue the way you do and shame on the others if they don't agree.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I agree also.My husband served in Iraq from Mar 2004 until Aug 2004 when he was wounded by 2 mortar attacks on his FOB.Soldiers who were left behind knew he was injured before he even called me,or my state military department.The following Monday,you bet I had my rear at the NG armory yelling.And one of the remaining soldiers lived across the street from me.He dad chewed him out,he himself a 20 year CG man.
    My husband died last Oct 26,2011.I was asked to waive my rights to his funeral planning by our two daughters & also the funeral director.He is buried where he didn't want to be,against his & my wishes.He wanted to be buried next to me,I was told " that isn't going to happen.I sat,I shook,I sobbed so hard I thought I was going into shock.I was not even given any card people brought to the church.Then I was screamed at by the Catholic Reverend to " move my car " ,and put it in the parking lot.I was parked in what I thought was a regular space.So I had my driver back it into a handicap space & place my DMV placard on my window.In the church I was yelled at again by the Catholic Reverend " what gives you the right to park in one of those places".I explained my disabilities to that Reverend.I was not even notified my husband had died by the hospital or what funeral home I wanted him to go to.I want him moved & brought home,where he wanted to be buried at,next to me.Their is so much much more to this story.
    Cheryl ( Lemmer ) Amling,widow of SSG Harold R. Amling

    ReplyDelete
  14. When I received "the call" from Afghanistan back in december, I was lost for a few minutes, to say the least. Still am.

    When things started to clear a little I knew I had to get the information to his family before his adult kids learned of their father's death on Facebook.

    Their mom got to them and told them herself, thankfully.

    But it was close. Some were already talking about it online from the FOB in Afghanistan.

    Dana Bernhardt
    "Mrs. Bombdog"

    "They honored Wayne with a Fallen Soldier ceremony. Soldiers lined both sides of the C-130 with the casket bearers solemnly marching Wayne to the aircraft. The soldiers all saluted Wayne as he passed and a prayer was said for him."

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Dana... I am so very sorry for your loss. Please know that I am sincerely grateful to your husband for his service and to you for your endurance and service. I am intimately familiar with the sacrifice. ~Lynn Bukowski

      Delete
  15. Good for you Amanda. You are correct not to post until DoD confirms. God bless you for your caring heart and thoughtfulness.

    ReplyDelete